Thread: In Denial
View Single Post
Old 04-26-2008, 12:21 PM   #91 (permalink)
SirokiFighter

Black Belt I
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Miyazaki 宮崎県, Japan
Posts: 540
Home Country:
SirokiFighter has a spectacular aura about



Quote:
Originally Posted by WC_Lun View Post
John55, has a point that I strongly agree with. Many schools, not just TKD, do not train realistically, but convince thier students that they are prepared for a street confrontation. Its akin to giving a soldier a gun loaded with blanks and sending him to war. Very foolish and very bad for the soldier.

These type of schools out-number the schools that train realistically by a great margin. However , they do serve a purpose. They are a gateway to the martial arts for many people. This is thier introduction. A few will grow enough and lose enough ego to look outside of thier McDojo to find real teaching. Most will not, and that's fine too. These poorly taught schools act as kind of a filter. I'm not sure this filter effect is enough to make up for the negative effect on the student though.

yes i agree. but he said schools that teach elbows and such arnt actuallly teaching tkd. that was the arguement. we said already very few schools train realisticalyy.
SirokiFighter is offline   Reply With Quote